Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Because every cop is a criminal and all the sinners saints

Among the cameos as we head toward home plate, I never expected to see Rousseau or Ana Lucia. So their brief appearances in "What They Died For," the penultimate ep. of the rapidly winding down Lost was a hoot.
So too was the ep. as a whole. We got a boatload of answers. We got some more major character deaths (Widmore and Zoe and presumably that's the last we see of Jacob). We got the storyline winnowed down to its climactic fundamentals, at least on Earth 1 (Jack and crew vs. Smokey over the light at the heart of the tunnel). And we got the pleasure of seeing more threads tied together on Earth 2 with characters bumping into each other all over the place and the fun of trying to figure out what Earth 2 Desmond actually is up to. (Presumably it has something to do with getting our characters back on an Oceanic flight, seeing as how he punk'd Jack with a phone call seemingly to get him back to the airport).
After seasons worth of speculation, it was good to finally see a clear cut, voice of God explainer of some of the major questions we've had. Yes, the chosen Losties all are there because they were flawed people ripe for some sort of redemption (sucks to be you, Rose, Bernard, Frogurt and everyone else who just happened to be on the flight). And the reasons why Kate is now off the list - actually having something to live for off the island - fits into that well.
And we got far too little Miles and Richard, though it was nice to see a return to form for Ben on Earth 1 (and indications of an interestingly creepy potential future for Rousseau and Earth 2 Ben).
We also got some annoyances. Ben is just able to gun down Widmore when previously there were some kind of never-explained rules that kept them from killing each other? Widmore turned from baddie to redeemed guy because Jacob enlightened him to the error of his ways? The character Zoe ended up being killed off without ever fulfilling any kind of role? Is Richard dead? That's what passes for instructions on how to safeguard this island - a few mumbled words, a swig of water and a "son, you're on your own" sendoff? Even the Greatest American Hero got an instruction manual.
And how is it that Jacob was able to go off island to the Losties to begin with? As we saw last week, the whole issue boils down to he and bro being unable to leave.
I imagine that a lot of these questions never are really going to get answered in a sort of 'leave that to the imagination' kind of way. And frankly, entertainment is rife with creations that had great buildups that didn't hold together under the light of day (I'm lookin' at you X-Files, Battlestar Galactica, numerous Stephen King and Dean Koontz novels), so having not everything spelled out from a storytelling standpoint is perhaps better, despite the inevitable howls of viewers who've been watching this as a puzzle to be solved.

5 comments:

Rick G. said...

So it looks like Jack is now the Di Penates of LOST Island after drinking the creek water that Jacob blessed with his holy mumblings. Me? I have a hard time making coffee with water that isn’t triple filtered, let alone slogging it out of what is basically an outdoor urinal trough but hey - it’s a small price to pay for being a small “G” god, I guess. One mystery was finally solved though – what does Jack carry in that ubiquitous backpack of his? Answer: A chalice. And a box of condoms, just in case.

There is an almost religious reverence going on that is hard to miss as things wind down. Fake Locke is evil incarnate and Jack is the savior. Something like that. I’m looking at Desmond as some kind of archangel. Kate and Sawyer could be Adam and Eve. Benjamin Linus is Judas Iscariot. Hugo is comic relief. All of the tailies and the Dharma folks are being slaughtered, so they don’t count. I look at them as the ant people that were drowned when Charlton Heston’s Moses made it across an entire ocean in 5 minutes. I may have missed a few days of catechism class, so I could be fuzzy on a couple of the details.

The mystery that I need solved is not the island. I’ve pretty much resigned myself to the inevitable purgatorial outcome of that piece of rock, but I’m dying to see how Earth II factors into all of this.

On the casualty list for this weeks episode: Richard was punted off into oblivion courtesy of Smokie, corporeal Locke made a human PEZ dispenser out of Zoe and Widmore was blasted by Benjamin if for no other reason than he wanted to snuggle up to Locke’s good side. It’s just a thinning of the herd at this point.

It’s hard to believe it’s coming to an end. Come Sunday, 7:00, I know exactly where I’ll be, and damn you Time-Warner if my screen freezes up like it did the other night.

Kristin said...

1. Props for The Greatest American Hero reference.
2. Boo for insinuating that BSG did not live up to its promise. It did.

Unknown said...

Me, I just want all of the stuff with Walt to pay off. During the season he was being held by the Others, other characters had visions of him in the jungle. But since Smokey can only pose as dead people.... I just think that would suck if the writers don't get around to addressing that. Especially if they use the copout that the actor has aged too much. Maybe Jacob can also appear as anyone he wants?

Unknown said...

Oh, and my money is still on Daneman's prediction from early on in the season: Desmond is gathering all of the sideways folks in order to get them all back on a plane. Which will then crash on a mysterious Island (run by Jack?). Roll credits.

MJL said...

Didn't someone at some point say the "rules have changed"? I'm vaguely recalling something after the point in time where Alex was killed by Keeny (Keemy?). That would/could explain Ben killing Widmore. That OR the fact that Jacob is dead and was killed by Ben. That switched something up too, right? Cause if Jacob was the protector of the island why can't Flocke just leave now? Like really dude row a boat. Smoke yourself off of the island. I thought Jacob was what was keeping him there...